Re: [GLOBAL-V6] New draft available: IPv6 Address Allocationand Assignment Global Policy

[Takashi Arano <arano@gblx.ad.jp>]

At 10:30 02/02/08, Takashi Arano wrote:
>So my small modification proposal is to replace "any LIR" with 
>   
>- ISP or organization who assigns and registers /48s to organizations 
>    other than itself
>
>Although it is still ambiguous, we know the perfect
>definition is impossible due to the nature of things.
>Actually, an enterprise or university which
>has subsidiaries in their networks like an ISP
>can be difficult to be categorized.
>
>Anyway, I believe this is better than just saying "any LIR",
>maybe because we can omit obvious end users. 

I am following up my own mail...

Someone may think there is a hole in this definition,
which is that any organization who disguise as an ISP 
could get /32. Yes, this rule does not prevent this. 

However, first there is no rules to prevent this kind of 
things. Second, this rule would give mental barriers to
applicants. This is a big difference.

The bottom of this idea is to give a /32 to all who
faithfully declares themselves as inside this category.

Regards,
Takashi Arano
P.S. I am still afraid I can convey my idea to you properly...

-
- This list (global-v6) is handled by majordomo@lists.apnic.net